Writer: The 'Mont
Pencils: Jon Bogdanove
Inks: Terry Austin
Letters: Tom Orzechowski
So, imagine someone says to you "Hey, internet guy or gal... c'mon a-my House of Ideas and write a story about the Fantastic Four fighting the X-Men. How's that sound?" Cherry gig, right? (I think the kids still say "cherry" and "gig". "The kids." What am I, Milton Berle?)
I mean, here you have two of the great iconic teams of superhero comics: One the loving family ready to do whatever it takes to save the world or each other, and the other a team of outcasts thrown together by genetic circumstance and a desire to bang redheads. (What? C'mon, try to act like you don't know Cyclops, Wolverine, and Charles Xavier all hunger for a slice o' Jean Grey's fire pie.)
Now imagine it's 1987, you're Chris Claremont, and you don't know the internet from an innertube. Now imagine you're a pretty twirly princess. Okay, that's good. Go back to the Claremont thing. You can keep the dress if you want. Imagine that, and you'd give us this story that's sort of about family, but mostly about a wispy, naked Kitty Pryde (oh, god, the search engine hits) and a crying Franklin Richards.
It seems like every random X-Men issue I pick up, either something horrible and senses-shattering(!) is happening or something horrible and senses-shattering(!) just happened and everyone's talking about it. Let's see... Uncanny X-Men 137? Yup, fighting on the moon, Jean dies. And there's one I've got somewhere wherein the X-Men are living in Australia and everyone thinks they're dead. And for whatever reason I read the first appearances of Jubilee and Gambit and, well, y'know. Jubilee. And Gambit. Tragic.
 Drink it in, nerds. |
This mini-series is no exception. Seems that in some issue of the regular X-Men series (this was back in the days when there was actually something you could call "the regular series") the X-Crew got their asses whupped by the Marauders. I think I saw the Marauders in an issue of OHOTMU once. All I remember is a generic-looking guy in grey with big elephant feet and some long-haired guy in a body stocking. Not only did these retreads beat up the X-Men, but, OH NOES! Kitty Pryde got her ass kicked so hard she's gone intangible and translucent! She's a living ghost! She dresses in purple and rides a white horse! Wait, no, she hangs out in one of those giant test tubes that all fictional scientists have. And — wait for it! — the only one who can save her is the greatest fictional scientist of all: REED RICHARDS! THE GUY FROM THE FANTASTIC FOUR WHO HAVE THEIR NAME ON THE COVER!
But it actually starts with Franklin having a bad dream about a book. The book, the little Aryan boy's dream tells him, will tear apart his family! It's a bad book! Very bad! What is it? It's alleged to be Reed Richard's diary, containing musings on mutation and Charles Xavier — because it's an X-Men cross-over, natch — and the effects cosmic rays might have on him, his best friend, his girlfriend, and her brother. What...? Reed did this all on PURPOSE!? Well, no, he didn't, but that's what this faux-diary says, and since there wouldn't be any tension otherwise, Ben, Sue and Johnny take it at its word. There also wouldn't be any tension if Reed had faith enough in his big brain to use the molecular recohesivator he just happened to be working on... which can save Kitty Pryde's life!
 Sue Storm, like many women, chose to get back at her husband by blasting off her clothes with an invisible forcefield and appearing naked on the internet. |
Besides She-Hulk taking Sue's place for the mission to save Ms. Pryde (after the obligatory fight-'n'-team-up with Magneto, which is preceeded by Jennifer studying for a mock trial of, who else, Magento), something should be said about this iteration of the X-Men: It sucks. Magneto in all his puffy purple-shirted glory, Dazzler, Longshot, Havok, Mullet-Rogue, Dazzler, Wolverine, Storm, Dazzler, Brit-Psylocke, and Dazzler. There's a brief shot of Nightcrawler and Colossus laid up in an infirmary, and... the guy who can teleport, the guy made of metal, and the intangible girl all got their clocks cleaned? And we're stuck with Dazzler? Miss Turns-Light-into-Sound? Somehow, I'm okay with eyebeams and telekinesis, but I always get hung up on this one. And somehow, when Doctor Doom comes along with a similar molecular recombobulator to save Kitty when Richards won't, Dazzler is the only one who says "Hey, guys, I fought Doom and he's a meanie. This is bad." Surely she's not the only one here who's fought Doom. And surely he would have put on some sunglasses and strangled her to death.
And that covers something like the first half of the mini-series. The rest is a bit more tedious. You ever write a paper for school as you read whatever's been assigned? Yeah, that's what I'm doing now. Let's see... X-Men fight some Doomsentries, Franklin astral-projects himself and hangs out with Kitty (which is kinda creepy), Ben drinks some coffee and saves some kid, Johnny hangs out with Alicia and she gives him some noble speech about loving his heart even though he burnt Storm up, and the rest of the FF decide that even if Reed is a dick, he's their dick and they'll hang out with him no matter what, and Doom makes with the sinister posing while healing Storm's burnt arm. Although Johnny Human Torch only grazed her upper arm, the whole thing ends up covered in burns. Doesn't matter, though, because in the MU a painful, potentially debilitating injury like a burn can be healed in a snap with the help of your local megalomaniac. No burn too big or too small!
 Suck it, Wolverine. |
And issue four... blah blah blah, think think think. I'm not one of those folks who minds thought balloons, but I swear there's something like 5,000 words worth of the damn things in these four issues, most of them focused on Reed's tortured, whiny, self-pitying internal monologue. If he'd stop thinking for five seconds and, I dunno, say out loud how that's not his journal and, y'know, they just saw Dr. Doom and it's probably something he did, this would've been a whole lot shorter. But consider this is coming from a reviewer who's never had an internal monologue much longer than "butt itches... ah, scratch... hungry... yay, Pringles." We do, however, get the best Thing/Wolverine fight ever where the ol' Canucklehead goes down like Guy Gardner. It's marred a bit by Rogue spouting the old 'hit 'em hard and fast" crap beforehand. Did Claremont have a rubber stamp for some of this stuff?
The rest is just Doom and Reed babbling about pseudo-science and the X-Men throwing their powers around. Oh, and Franklin pouting and showing that he's stupid enough to stand between his father and Doctor Doom. And we're supposed to believe a kid making puppy eyes will make Doom turn away? I call "Doombot" on that one.
It takes Sue nearly four issues to realize Doom planted that diary. Kitty's still a foggy broad in a tube, but she's been "stabalized" and will coalesce gradually. If I had spent a buck fifty an issue on this back in 1987 I'd've been pissed. The paper's nice, though, and has held up well. And Jon Bogdanove draws a pretty cool She-Hulk, whatever the hell she's doing in this story.
My upraised middle finger is the focused totality of my disdain for X-Men comics not written by Grant Morrison. Skip this unless you find it in a dime bin or maybe laying on the sidewalk somewhere.
BONUS "CRYING FRANKLIN RICHARDS" GALLERY |
   |
  |